Skip to main content
Free Journal Assessment

Assess Your Journal

Not sure where your journal stands? Send us the link. We review it against what indexes, authors and readers expect, and send you a scorecard with next steps.

Free of chargeScorecard in 2 business daysClear recommendations
Journal assessment scorecard
ScorecardFree
2 business daysTurnaround
What We Do

What We Check

A practical review by people who build and index journals, not an automated scan.

Indexing and Visibility

Where your journal appears: Google Scholar, DOAJ, Crossref, Scopus and discipline indexes, and what is missing.

Identifiers

ISSN shown correctly, DOIs on every article, metadata completeness and reference linking.

Policies and Ethics

Peer review, ethics, licensing, authorship and archiving policies, and whether they are published clearly.

Website Quality

Design, speed, mobile use, the pages indexes look for and how easy it is for authors to submit.

Editorial Workflow

How submissions, reviews and production run today, and where time is lost.

Scorecard and Plan

A scored report with the issues in priority order and the steps to fix them.

How It Works

How the Assessment Works

You see progress at every step, and nothing goes live until you approve it.

01

Submit

Send us your journal URL and a few details through the form below.

Request received
02

Review

Our team audits the website, identifiers, policies and indexing.

Audit done
03

Report

You receive a scorecard with recommendations within two business days.

Scorecard delivered
04

Discuss

We walk you through the report on a call, with no obligation.

Clear next steps
Reviewing a journal and giving feedback
Who It Is For

For Editors Who Want a Clear Picture

Editors usually know something is holding their journal back, but not exactly what. An outside review shows the gaps in order of importance.

The assessment is free. You decide what to do with it, with us or on your own.

  • Journals planning an index application
  • Journals rejected by an index
  • Journals with falling submissions
  • New editors taking over a journal
  • Publishers reviewing their titles
  • Journals considering a platform change
In Depth

What the Scorecard Covers

How we assess a journal

The assessment follows the same checklists that indexing bodies use, plus the practical checks we make when we take over a journal. The result is a scorecard with a score for each area and a short list of what to fix first.

Visibility

We search for your journal and recent articles in Google Scholar, Crossref, DOAJ, Scopus and discipline databases, and we check how your articles appear in a normal Google search. Missing or incomplete listings are noted with the reason.

Identifiers and metadata

We check that the ISSN is displayed and correct, that articles carry DOIs that resolve, and that DOI records include authors, ORCID iDs, abstracts, licences and references. Thin metadata is one of the most common findings.

  • ISSN display and registration
  • DOI coverage and resolution
  • Metadata completeness
  • Google Scholar meta tags

Policies, ethics and transparency

We read your policy pages the way a DOAJ or Scopus reviewer would: are the review process, ethics statement, licensing, fees, archiving and board information present, clear and consistent with what the journal actually does?

Website and workflow

We test the site on a phone and a desktop, check speed and security, and walk through the submission process as an author would. We also ask about how reviews and production are run today, to see where time is lost. The scorecard ends with recommendations in order of impact.

What Is Included

Exactly What You Get

Included items are part of the standard service. Optional items are quoted separately when you need them.

ItemDetailsStatus
Visibility checkIndex and search engine presenceIncluded
Identifier checkISSN, DOIs, metadata completenessIncluded
Policy reviewAgainst DOAJ and Scopus expectationsIncluded
Website reviewDesign, speed, mobile, required pagesIncluded
Workflow reviewSubmission, review and production processIncluded
ScorecardScores per area with prioritised actionsIncluded
Review callWalk-through of the findingsIncluded
Fix implementationCarrying out the recommended workOptional

The assessment and the review call are free, with no obligation.

Standards and Tools

What We Work With

ScorecardGoogle ScholarDOAJ criteriaScopus criteriaCrossrefISSNSite speedMobile check
Samantha Technologies developer at work

Why Samantha Technologies

One Team for Your Whole Journal

We have built and hosted websites and software since 2007. Our journal team combines publishing know-how with 18+ years of web experience.

18+ Years of Experience

We have delivered 1000+ projects, including journal, university and publisher websites.

Honest Advice

ISSN, DOI, Scopus and indexing bodies make their own decisions. We prepare you properly and never promise what they must decide.

Everything in One Place

Software, website, hosting, design, indexing support and marketing come from one team with one contact.

Support After Launch

Call, email or WhatsApp us, Monday to Saturday, 9:30 AM to 6:30 PM IST. We answer within 2 to 4 business hours.

Request Your Free Journal Assessment

Share your journal link and a few details. You get a scorecard and recommendations within two business days.

Frequently Asked
Questions

Still have a question?

Talk to our team — the first consultation is free.

Book Free Consultation
Yes. There is no charge and no obligation. We offer it because most journals that see their scorecard want help with at least some of it, and that is how we earn the work.
Your journal URL and a few details about the platform and your goals. If some pages require a login, a temporary reviewer account helps but is not required.
Yes. We assess journals on OJS, on custom websites, on our platform and on other systems.
Journal Publishing

Find Out Where Your
Journal Stands

Request a free assessment. You get a clear scorecard, and you decide what happens next.

Back to top Call +91 98944 14299 Chat on WhatsApp